Trip
to the land of smile part 2
Meeting
people from different countries to discuss experiences on similar concern is
very informative and a rich a venue of learning.
The
Ateneo School of governance was creative enough to device an avenue for an
exchange of experiences and share ideas for enrichment through interactive
dialogue.
I
was in Thailand last july 16 to 19 for a regional conference on extractive
industries.
The
main objective of the conference centers on community scorecards and citizen
report cards if they are viable tools in social accountability in the
extractive industries.
The
specific objectives are sharing lessons and insights gained from the community
scorecard and citizen report card experience. To develop new tools for a social
accountability application at home based on the tool kit devised by the World
Bank institute and to apply it on a second run in constructively engaging more stakeholders
in the extractive industries.
After
the review validation and assessment of the social accountability tools in the
extractive industries, tales of the researchers were shared. We all had a
common experience in dealing with government people and communities.
There
are however some differences in engaging with the extractive industry people.
In
countries like Mongolia there seems to be little problem in the stake holders
because before operating to extract minerals, obligations, taxes and
entitlements are all in place and agreed upon by the stakeholders.
Indonesian
government sometimes does not do what is required according to the researchers
from that country. While in Cambodia effects of the long time repressions are
still visible and the researchers are coping up with it. Timore Leste has their
particular way of dealing with their communities.
The
other researchers have their unique tales to tell and I will try to bring them
out in my next upcoming article.
The CVM, ANSA research that I Hector kawig conducted
at philex mines was a complete surprise. We found ourselves in the middle of a
controversy. We found out those IP leaders, LGUs and Mine officials were
working cohesively promoting their self-interest at the expense of the majority
of the IPs. We believe these are happening to other mining communities here in
Benguet but somebody must come out and bring it in the open.
Proposals were made for a
second run of the social accountability tools with innovations that may bring
better results for a change.
Bringing
the ASEAN vision and declarations into play in dealing with our engagement to
stake holders is challenging in this second run of community scoring that
involves more stakeholders.
Global
standards currently applied and recognized can remake social cultural and
economic justice a reality in the affected communities.
The
Philippine team devised a strategy and action plan to apply in the second run
of the community scorecard to include a larger scope of its coverage.
Policies
and decisions in the national and regional levels are not reaching the grass
root level in the light of the global standard. Therefore the sentiments of the
communities as determined by the community scorecards must be addressed in future
constructive engagements.
The current situation in the
indigenous cultural communities as to the status of the social accountability
tools is in the negative. Transparency accountability and participation are
interpreted by the service providers in their own terms.
.Openness
of the service providers are lip service but not in practice.
.Access
to information is not readily available.
.Organized
citizen groups exist but must level off regarding differences on the extractive
industries in order work together for the good of the indigenous cultural
communities.
.The
cultural context of a persistent indigenous people’s Identity surrounding the
facts and situations of this IPs in the light of the destruction of the land
where they have planted their roots is unacceptable. The recently concluded CSC
research in Philex mining area has uncovered a concerted plot against these
indigenous cultural communities. The key actors in these conspiracies are no
other than the IP leaders, politicians and the company officials. To
sum it all;
IP’s hide their feeling just like any other Filipino. But
Igorots have their peculiarities that are different from place to place. The
anxiety that concern us today is the vulnerability of an IP’s identity. It is
so fragile that it can easily be absorbed by the mainstream molded by western
standards.
Our identity differentiates us from
the rest having a culture that was and should ever be. A belief at the center
of a web of practices that produce an all-encompassing union with nature rooted
in the harsh land we were born and nurtured.
Others dismissed this as a figment
of the imagination of an ignorant and backward people but there is much to
discover in the hidden feelings of an IP.
The greed of the west and fellow
countrymen came to our lands and begun digging and spoiling the earth where we
anchored our aspirations and dreams even our very existence.
Our fields and terraces that reflect
our art and culture were inundated by the siltation of mining waste.
Now the essence of our wellbeing
kept hidden in the deepest chambers are slowly being eroded and silted.
What is left is just wishing for a
moment of bliss to standstill, at a wink of an eye lasting till eternity......
No comments:
Post a Comment